Hongzhang Wang , Hao Ren , Aziz Khan , Qijin He , Yali Zhao , Lihua Zhang , Yuee Liu , Geng Li , Yong Wang , Jiwang Zhang , Bin Zhao , Baizhao Ren , Peng Liu
Abstract
The North China Plain (NCP) is a globally important maize production region, yet its smallholder-dominated systems face growing tensions among productivity, resource-use efficiency, and environmental sustainability. Quantifying the synergies and trade-offs among these dimensions is essential for sustainable intensification but remains lacking at the farm level. Here, we combined a survey of 1674 households across the NCP with a four-year, ten-site field experiments to examine interconnections among grain yield, nitrogen use efficiency (NUE), energy use efficiency (EUE), greenhouse gas emission intensity (GHGi), and an aggregated sustainability index (ASI). Only 1.2% of farms achieved high performance in all four indicators; gaps between top-performing and average farms reached 25.6% for grain yield, 56.1% for NUE, 48.0% for EUE, and 41.6% for GHGi. Yield-targeted farms showed the lowest NUE and EUE and the highest GHGi, whereas farms prioritizing NUE or GHGi attained the highest ASI, revealing a fundamental trade-off between yield-oriented management and sustainability in this high-input system. Boundary-line analysis showed that maximum NUE, minimum GHGi, and highest ASI were associated with yields 16.1%-20.8% above the farm average, indicating that sustainability and moderate yield gains are compatible. An integrated high-yield and high-efficiency practice outperformed conventional farming, increasing yield, NUE, and EUE by 28.3%, 41.7%, and 18.8% while reducing GHGi by 29.4%. Our findings suggest that shifting production targets from grain yield maximization toward balanced efficiency and emission reduction, implemented through region-specific integrated agronomic practices, could reconcile productivity with sustainability in NCP summer maize systems.
Paper Linkage:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eja.2026.128383
Chinese